These two scare me, how come the maxilla and mid face appear to have moved forward but the mandible/chin seems to have stayed behind in both cases? Were they advanced the same?
I think his maxilla was advanced too much. He started with a strong bone structure, but the maxillary advancement seemed to wash it out. The change in his 3/4 view is what bothered me the most -- he had originally had some concavity under his cheekbones, which is desirable in men, but advancing the maxilla caused it to become convex. This is what he should have looked like imo.
It's actually quite similar to his starting point, which is why I don't think he needed surgery at all.