"What is typically considered ugly that you personally find attractive?"
In some circles (including among surgeons), the "importance" of anteface and wide/square jaws is, I think, overstated. There are plenty of good-looking people who don't have these. I wouldn't consider them requisites of beauty, and in some cultures people get surgery to achieve the opposite (maxillary setback/extractions/anterior segmental osteotomy, shaving jaws/cheekbones).
Re: what people say vs. what they do, some people said their boyfriends/husbands have crooked teeth, are balding or shorter, etc.