Well...I guess MANY of his disgruntled patients chose to write their horrifying experiences on "RATEMDS.com". He is all over that site and it's not pretty!
Always keep away from surgeons that do alot of marketing. These are usually the worst surgeons with no ethics, only thinking about money. Eppley for example, is a good salesman and a (very) bad surgeon.
This guy does no marketing. I'd say its the exact opposite, he feels anything besides surgery is beneath him. For example after my surgery he refused to speak with me and sent out a first year resident instead.
Maybe he was embarrassed by his work. You had a bad result, right?
Don't forget alot of reviews on the net are written by the business.