OP, moving the maxilla forward a second time puts a lot of risk to your nose widening more. The photos are no longer up, so I can't see how much it widened the first time. This is one reason I don't like it. In the second photo you posted, from memory, your lower jaw looked too far out for your upper face. So moving the mandible back would make more sense. Cutting the mandible a second time increases the risk of nerve damage, as you might know. So there's that to factor in. I agree with others who said you looked good in the first photo right out of surgery (again, from memory), but you were swollen and in general photos are some of the worst records for assessing anything. You mentioned soft tissue in a post, and again from memory you were Asian and appeared to have thin soft tissue that is somewhat typical in Asians. This will make any movement more apparent since the tissue doesn't hide anything, and it's another reason I think mandible, especially if you miss your old face. Mandible would get you closer to the old face, though you have to accept the actual old face is gone forever. My big issue with the maxilla is moving it a second time puts so much risk to the nose area. It's worth considering because it did look good in that one photo, but I wouldn't consider it without more info from the surgeon. Maybe request an emergency consultation to go over everything. Good luck, buddy. Tough situation.