I guess it's subjective, but we seem to agree that he looked 'normal' / good already with his original nose. I wonder why it bothered him so much that he decided to get surgery for it, but anyway, if he likes the result, good for him - that's all that matters.
The more I look at him the more I'm 50/50...
If I saw the guy on the left on the street, I'd think he's a hit man. Guy on the right I'd think he's a music engineer or something. Both look similar to me in terms of attractiveness, so it's more about what I associate the person with.