I think you should go for the option which will give you A LOT more length. And a fairly aggressive genio (yes have the implant removed), potentially with a lengthening genio as well. Look up pictures of the actress Ahna O'reilly --I think you should use her jawline as a model for the type of look you'd like to achieve. Part of it is that her jaw angles are wider than yours, but bringing the jaws forward will give you some additional width as well. I'm usually in favor of more aggressive transformational changes, so take my advice with a grain of salt, but if you were aiming for perfection, I'd certainly advise the more aggressive solution. You need a lot more mandible, chin projection in my opinion.