Sorry I meant the third surgeon, but I will get another consult even with the second one to understand why he thinks CW is a better option for me. I removed the pics because after 2 days nobody else replied to the thread, I just reposted them
Well, it's certainly something where opinions could differ as to which rotation to use as a functions of the trade-offs with either. See my reply #1 in this thread (parts 2 and 3). But with either CW or CCW, it does look like the maxilla would need to be brought 'forward' to bring the teeth closer to the lips albeit on a different 'vector' or angle of inclination.