So I go and see yet another surgeon. This time I didn't blab who my surgeon was. He told me that no-one does more surgeries than him in the state, if not the country.
Le Fort I is all I need, and re-evaluate in 12 months.
My face is too wide for modified Le Fort III (it will make it wider).
My cheekbones are asymmetrical. Le Fort III would exacerbate the asymmetry. So maybe implants to fix give under-eye support. But implants suck. He really regrets putting them into patients when he was younger and was willing to "experiment" at patient's request (and they were the wrong patients - "lunatics", "but, hey no-one sued me"). He only does custom medpor a few times a year when someone's face is totally messed up by an accident. Other than that, they are evil for the same reason chin implants are bad - "facial bones and muscles want to be together". Oversize malar implants can in fact cause scleral show.
HA paste is bulls**t as well. It migrates, resorbs. Waste of time.
Other interesting tid bits:
BSSO does not change the genial angles, only IVRO does, but it's dangerous and no-one does it anymore.
New planning software now even has ethnicity options.
Modified Le Fort III is only really for syndromal cases (Crouzon and the like). Says he's done less than 5. 1% risk of blindness. But he showed me the modified Le Fort III he did on a Class III man. Name, operation pictures (cuts under the eyes) and all. I asked him "what about patient confidentiality?" - "I don't give a f**k". The dude looked old and haggard. Narrow face, eyeballs practically hanging out. Scleral show. All fixed. He did not become handsome, just normal. Was ugly before. I really wonder what his real age was. He looked 50 years old. Maybe it was because of the deformity. Anyway the good doc said you can jump one level when you fix your deformity. Said I was average, will be "good looking, but no model" after surgery. So if you are ugly due to the deformity, you become average, etc.. Anyway, apparently this dude's personality changed from introvert to extrovert and he lost his job because of it.
I finally mentioned my surgeon. He said no-one besides US does more orthognathic surgeries. Hehe. "And we won't ignore you if things go wrong. Other surgeons just go quiet and will send you for second opinions. We will fix you if we make a mistake". So it's either him or my surgeon. No-one else has their kind of volume of surgeries.
Said that my surgeon is a real Le Fort III expert, loves doing them and will do them any chance he gets. So the fact that he doesn't think it's a good idea for me, means that it's not a good idea period.
tldr; From all the non-syndromal modified Le Fort III pictures I've seen, you need to have serious scleral show and have bulging eyes practically hanging out of their orbits. But it's not the white-unicorn operation that it's made out to be. Surgeons that know how to perform it, do perform it when it's appropriate.