I've seen a LOT of Y's work and enough to know that the people with the most eye POTENTIAL end up looking the best and those with inherent issues with the eyes--especially asymmetry where one eye is really 'off'-- start noticing it more even after it's technically improved. If I were you, I would specifically ask to see photos of 'unWONKING' a wonky eye.
You have some kind of opthomology thing or inner orbital socket issue going on. You have something where one eye is looking at you and the other one looks like it's doing something else. ('Lazy eye'?) Sure, he will kick up some improvement to the eye area. But I think you should set your expectations to 'less asymmetry' and leave it at that.
@Kavan You're right, it's probably best to set my expectations low. I know that people have commented on whether or not I should do the jaw implants, but what's your opinion on the midface implants (technically a combined cheek + orbital rim implant)? Aside from improving the eye area to at least a mild-moderate extent, do you think I'd look better with more anterior projection (which Dr. Y is giving me quite a lot of at ~5 mm) of the cheekbones? I specifically told him I didn't want any submalar augmentation and that I wanted it to look masculine, defined, etc. I'm not sure if it's possible to tell in any of the photos I linked you to, but I actually have a relatively flat midface.
Here are a couple photos I took just now that give you an idea of just how much my cheeks lack anterior projection (also note the droopy/retracted lower eyelids):
https://imgur.com/a/tNh1UG4You can also see that the chin is fairly weak as well. Dr. Y's plan for the chin is to add 5 mm of additional projection, which is a bit more than 2.5 nickels' widths, so that seems fairly conservative, I think. He also is planning on making it a bit wider to increase squareness.
Do you think I'm most likely to get a good result if I just do the cheeks and chin and leave the jaw alone?