Are you insane?
The first girl looks extremely good in the after.
Better than the second girl, for sure. Yes the gonial implants are fake looking IF you have done research on those topics. Normal people wouldn't notice at all. It looks strong and good.
And I'm not a Sailer fan usually.
I think Sailer gets critized too harshly. His patients are usually older adults, so it's not like he is disfiguring kids who cannot make informed decisions. Sailer's patients go to him, because they share his vision of beauty and want to radically change their appearance - and that is exactly what he does for them.
Personally, I think his blanket approach (slap a hyper ante face on everyone) to beauty is wrong, but he does have some good results. And no one of his patients can complain about looking underdone, so if you decide on having surgery with him, at least you can be sure to have a vastly altered appearance afterwards.
The woman in the before and after does look better after her surgery with him.