See therein lies the issue.
I've seen it plenty of times! Guys that aren't so particularly attractive with girls that are beautiful. Bars in NYC, Boston, Chicago. I travel a lot and have seen it live.
Im not saying y'all are wrong, but there is as much, if not more, riding on the ability to CREATE the attraction via conversation, body language, being masculine, as there is on the way you appear.
Now if you walk into the nightclub with sweats and beat up sneakers, no. But you get the jist