Seems you're not getting much feedback specifically with your cheeks/nose. I'd suggest to show like for like photos, one against the other, before vs after, with different profile shots (however possible that is).
Also, I'm curious how many mm your maxilla was brought forward? I've heard people complain their cheeks look haggard from this surgery, as though bringing the maxilla forward stretches the malar pads / cheek area out (I don't know). Also a hunch with your OP doc, I'd try to get exactly what your surgical plan was from him for verification purposes. CCW - you've said that CCW rotation would actually help puff out cheeks, right? I wonder how much is 'too little CCW' to be noticeable whatsoever.
If you'd humor me, was there anything wrong with your chin implant prior to removal? Living with a chin implant myself but my smile has been somewhat hampered since.