I'm not sure if there is any other surgical field where opinions between surgeons regarding treatment plans can vary as radically as they can in orthognathic surgery. This can also be a regional thing. For example in my lucky country, nobody does CCW rotations, as in nobody in a country of 30 million. That's just the local surgical school. In a place like Texas, you'll find that a great many surgeons will, because surprise, surprise, that's where CCW was invented. Swiss and German surgeons favour chin wings now as a way to simulate CCW rotation, because, surprise, surprise, it was invented (or at least popularised) in Switzerland.
So don't despair. Since you're in Europe, consult with Alfaro. FWIW, while your upper lip does protrude, I don't think it's that big of a deal - profiles are overrated.